• STUDENTS
  • ALUMNI
  • FACULTY
  • STAFF
  • LIBRARY
Cooley Law Logo
MENU
  • APPLY
  • J.D.
      • J.D. Program
      • Prospective Students
      • Apply Now
      • Tuition & Financial Aid
      • Scholarships
      • FAQ
      • Contact Admissions
      • Campus Locations
      • Course Catalog
      • Schedule Options
      • Study Abroad
      • Our Student Body
      • Academic Calendar
      • U.S. Legal Studies for Foreign Attorneys
  • EXPERIENTIAL LEARNING
      • Social Justice Clinics
      • Community Service Clinics
      • Externships
      • Simulation Courses
      • Competitions
  • MAKE A GIFT
      • Giving Tuesday 2021
      • Annual Fund
      • DEI Champions
      • Merit Scholarship Fund
      • Planned Giving
      • Cooley Society Membership
      • Donor Honor Roll
  • ABOUT
      • Mission, Values, and Vision
      • Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion
      • Home of the National Legal Mentoring Consortium
      • Commitment to Social Justice and Access
      • Leadership & Administration
      • Blog
      • Campus Locations
      • Title IX and Campus Safety
      • Media Requests
      • Consumer Information
      • Jobs

Search

My Encounter with Canned Briefs

After more than three decades at the lectern, Cooley Law School Distinguished Professor Emeritus Otto Stockmeyer has retired from full time teaching, but maintains a continuing interest in factors that help law students achieve their personal best. Here he explains why students should write out their own case briefs rather than rely on commercial “canned” ones.

otto_stockmeyerStudents may wonder why Cooley Law School does not sell canned briefs in the bookstore. The simple answer is that the faculty has voted, several times over the years, not to allow the bookstore to carry them.

Why? Because we believe that students need to brief cases themselves as part of the learning process. We realize that students can acquire canned briefs elsewhere. But we don’t want to enable their acquisition, or give students the impression that the law school recommends them.

Recently, I discovered another reason for keeping canned briefs out of the bookstore: they are unreliable and may actually contribute to misunderstandings. Here’s how it came about.

Officially, I’ve retired from teaching. But from time to time colleagues would run into a situation where they could not attend a scheduled class. Make-up classes are difficult to schedule and inconvenient for students. So I would get invited to substitute in Contracts from time to time.

One term I was preparing to teach Contracts II for a colleague, including the case of Bright v Ganas. I knew that another professor had recently written a law review article on the case, so I Googled the case name to see if I could locate her article. I did not find it - but what I found instead was a brand-name publisher’s canned brief on the case.

Curious, I Googled the other cases on the syllabus for that day and read canned briefs of them as well. My reaction? The briefs were woefully inadequate in several respects, and were dead-bang wrong on a couple of important points. They have the potential to embarrass any student who relies on them when reciting in class.

This represents a small sampling, to be sure, and other purveyors of canned briefs exist whose “products” may be better, or worse. But in my mind, this experience reaffirms the correctness of the faculty’s decision to ban all canned briefs from the bookstore. And if we ever relent, at least we should slap on cigarette-pack style warning labels that say, “Reliance on canned briefs can be hazardous to your academic success.”

Some years ago, I asked the first Cooley student who graduated with a perfect 4.0 grade-point average what she thought was the basis for her law school success. She replied without hesitation: “I never stopped briefing.” Long after most students were book-briefing, or had given up briefing cases entirely, she briefed every case, in every course, every term. Students who want to maximize their success should follow her example, and shun canned briefs.

More Blogs By Professor Stockmeyer


An expanded version of this article originally appeared in The Pillar for May 2012. Recently the bookstore began stocking canned briefs. Sales have been negligible. But the discussion has started!

More on Canned Briefs: They are harmful to law students! by Legal Skills Prof Blog

How Inaccurate are Canned Briefs? by Legal Skills Prof Blog

Tags: Cooley Faculty
Back to Blog
  • Tweet

Related Articles

Law School Success Tips Have Proven Validity

This blog article outlining Distinguished Professor Emeritus Otto Stockmeyer's law school success...
Read More

Five Reasons to Choose Cooley Law School

Post-graduate studies in any program are a huge commitment, but law school is especially...
Read More

The 10 Habits of Highly Successful Law Students

At Cooley Law School, we’ve spent years paying close attention to the consistent habits shared by...
Read More

Subscribe to Email Updates

Recent Posts

Posts by Topic

  • Cooley Faculty (135)
  • Cooley Alumni (123)
  • Cooley Students (84)
  • Legal Education (78)
  • Faculty Experts (72)
  • Tampa Bay Campus (27)
  • Diversity (24)
  • Cooley Law School Students (21)
  • Dean's Fellow (19)
  • From Where I Stand (18)
  • Awards (13)
  • Faculty Research & Scholarship (12)
  • Innocence Project (12)
  • Military Students (11)
  • Plain language (11)
  • Study Abroad (11)
  • Multicultural Lawyering (10)
  • Michigan Lawyer Employment Data (7)
  • Cooley Law School History (6)
  • Lansing Campus (5)
  • Library Blog Series (5)
  • Weekend Program (5)
  • Equal Access to Justice (4)
  • Kimberly O'Leary (4)
  • Legal Ethics (4)
  • Bar Exam Advice (3)
  • Externships (3)
  • International Law Faculty Experts (3)
  • Resiliency (3)
  • Continuous Improvement (2)
  • Cooley Career Office (2)
  • Service & Integrity (2)
  • online learning (2)
  • Cooley Mission (1)
  • Homeland & National Security Law Review (1)
  • LL.M. (1)
  • LSAT Prep (1)
  • Tribute (1)
see all
Cooley Law Logo

Cooley Law School
300 South Capitol Avenue, Lansing, MI 48933
Tampa Oaks I, 12802 Tampa Oaks Boulevard, Suite 150, Tampa, FL 33637
(517) 371-5140

Contact Us

Contact Admissions

Read Our Blog

Full Sitemap

Get Adobe Acrobat Reader

Consumer Information

In corde hominum est anima legis. | The spirit of the law is in the human heart.

Cooley Law School is an independent, private, non-profit educational institution accredited by the American Bar Association and the Higher Learning Commission. 

Read non-discrimination policy

If you encounter accessibility barriers while on our website, please notify our Accessibility Office using the Inaccessible Content Notification Form.

© 2024 Cooley Law School
Designed By InVerve Marketing